I started wearing makeup in the first place because I was sick of people telling me that I looked tired all the time (even though I was, in fact, tired all the time) and ever since that day, I have been on a quest for the perfect potion, the snake oil of my dreams, to banish these under eyes.
The elevator at my job is filled with nothing but mirrors, which leads to a lot of examination by me. I noticed today that my under eye area was looking pretty crepe-y. I'm 35 now and these "fine lines and wrinkles" are upon me. I'm of two minds about this. There is the wise part of me, who recognizes the gift of aging and who tells me I should embrace my laugh lines as a sign of a life well lived, and then there is the Norma Desmond part of me who wants to draw the shades and find the nearest plastic surgeon to handle this shizz.
My current under eye area regime consists of the following:
Smashbox Color Correcting Primer
Benefit The Pore-Sessional primer (I don't really love this primer. Some people do. I prefer Smashbox. But I bought it, and it was expensive, so... its getting used. I usually put the Smashbox on first all over my face, and then the Benefit under my eyes and down my nose into my smile lines, because its thicker.)
Laura Geller Baked Liquid Radiance Foundation in the shade "Fair"
Too Faced Air Buffed BB Cream in the shade "Snow Glow" (note, this is for brightening, which is why it is so light. This would look insane on the rest of my face.)
And then over that, I use the highlight color from the Balm Voyage II Palette, its called "Kuwakaribisha," according to their helpfully informative website.
So all of that together is about $200 worth of stuff I spackle under my eyes in the morning, and it still isn't enough to get rid of the dark circles, except in very forgiving lighting.
I have tried everything I can think of, but there isn't really anything, and probably won't ever be anything short of surgery that totally takes the bags away. So, I'm left with doing what I can for the circles at least.
The one product that I keep hearing about, but have yet to try is It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye. Since I was already at Ulta today, taking advantage of their after Christmas savings, I decided to pick some of this too. Also, I really decided today was the day when I looked at myself up close in the elevator and had to call on the name of Jesus. Jay-Z says 30 is the new 20, but he only has one child, two if you count Kanye.
After trying out their supply I couldn't really decide between the shades "Fair" and "Medium." The salesgirl asked me if I was looking for brightening or concealing, and though my first instinct was to say "brightening" I had to be honest with myself that this mission was about concealing. This stuff is powerful, and to use it for brightening could, I think, end up looking really scary.
Someone on the internet once said something along the lines of "though she is tiny, she is fierce." That's this stuff. I know what you're thinking, "$24 for .28oz?? I thought this was a budget blog??" Well, yes, okay, but I am telling you, this tube will last forever. My grandchildren will be using this tube. Not really. If Donald Trump doesn't kill us all, and I am actually lucky enough to have grandchildren, they'll probably wear holographic makeup. Or we'll all be avatars by then, who can say. The point is, this tube actually has a lot of product. Only the teeniest tiniest dab is required to do both eyes. This cream is THICK. It is serious, and it isn't playing around.
Hopefully, the before and afters here are pretty obvious. While it didn't take the dreaded bags away, I feel like it did a pretty great number on the dark circles. All of these pictures were taken within just a few minutes of each other, so as to get basically identical lighting and have really the only difference be the Bye Bye Under Eye. I have to say, I was impressed.
The only down side (because there is always a down side) is that after about an hour I noticed that the product made itself niiiice and comfy down in the fine lines under my eyes. I went into the bathroom at work (fluorescent lights are nobody's friend) but in absence of just avoiding bad lighting for the rest of myself, which seems a viable if laborious option, I feel like I need to find yet and still another primer to keep the makeup from settling. I'm very open to suggestions if anyone has any that they love.
I tried to get a photo of the creasy line action here. You can sort of see it, but it does not do justice to the settling that was occurring in real life. You've been warned.
The interwebs tell me that Ulta also sells a travel size version of this product, it was not available at the store I went into. It also only seems to be available in the shade, "medium" which happens to be what I have on, but then wouldn't really work for everyone. If yours happens to have it, and you happen to wear medium, you might give it a try and see if you like it.
My verdict is that I really, really love how much it covers my dark circles, so I will definitely keep using it. I wish it didn't settle so much though, and if anyone has an under eye primer that they love, please let me know!