When I started following different beauty influencers in the last few years, I learned the elf has made very strong comeback, repackaging and rebranding into something more substantial. Jeffree Star, who is the goddess of liquid lipstick, is a big fan of elf, and it was his review of their Mad for Matte 2 palette is what made me get interested in them again.
Also, elf has free shipping, at, like, $20-$25 depending on when you go on their website, and you can get a literal shit ton of stuff for that amount of money. Who doesn't love getting big boxes of makeup? I know I do.
I did some other elf reviews back in January and I have followed them on social media for about a year. I saw this on their Instagram a few weeks ago, and even though it was really an ad for their tinted wax eyebrow pencil, I had a come to Jesus moment with that lip color!
Gorgeous, right? Now, I will tell you forever, that you can never go wrong with a red lip, and thats true. Its a timeless classic. But, you can also never go wrong with a berry color like this. Its bright enough for summer, and yet deep enough for winter. I commented on the picture and asked what the lip color was. I ask this question a lot on instagram and twitter. It almost never gets answered. Usually I get no response, and then sometimes, your B list celebrities and reality stars will answer me but they tell me they don't remember or they mixed several shades, which, #girlbye. I know you know. You know that I know that you know. But nobody is trying to rep a company or a color without talking to them first, which I get. Nobody wants to love something for free if they could be getting a brand ambassador paycheck for it, and, occasionally, you will run into a situation where the brand doesn't want you. So they play like they don't know.
As a side note, the biggest exception, for me, to this rule, was Jodie Sweetin, who actually responded to a comment I left on a People magazine article to tell me what her lip color was. I can't even remember what the brand was now, but I remember that it was a bomb red. Anyway, shout out to Stephanie Tanner.
To my great surprise, this Anna Nicolee person, who was very lovely, sent me a DM identifying the color and product as Berry Sorbet Matte Lip Color. Which, another funny story, I am just now realizing as I wrote this that I bought the wrong thing. I actually bought the Matte LIQUID LIPSTICK in the shade Berry Sorbet which is the same, but different. So never mind. Blah. This is why reading is fundamental kids.
Anyway, I hopped on over to the elf website to, in fact, buy the wrong lipstick, and not the one I was there for, and while I was there, because who wants to miss out on $25 free shipping, I picked up a few more things.
I actually decided to pick up the same tinted wax brow pencil she was using, except I got mine in
So, the Berry Sorbet. I was going to be all glib and compare my goofy iPhone picture to Anna's professional shot and lit one, but it turns out that we aren't even wearing the same product, so thats kind of useless. At any rate, here is the one I got:
I am still super in love with the color, though I suspect I would like the formula of the non-liquid color better. I suspect it has more of a satin finish, whereas the liquid, you can see, is super matte. I happen to really love a good, dry liquid matte (which I why I own so much Colourpop) so typically this would be right in my wheel house. But I feel like this particular color with a little bit more of a shine might be more fun. Also, I feel like I know a thing or two about liquid lips at this point, and I have never, ever in life seen an applicator like the one this has:
Seriously, what is the hole in the middle for? I know someone out there knows. Please, share with the rest of the class. I'm dying to know what its purpose is.
Now, what I will tell you that I love love love love and plan to buy approximately 75 more of is the eyebrow pencil. I haven't had the time to get my brows waxed in a real long time. I'm kind of limping them along on my own, and shit is getting real over here. Also, I find that as I age, my brows aren't as thick as they used to be, so its nice to have something that can sort of tame them and get everything flowing in the right direction and fill in the sparse spots too. elf makes a wax brow pencil with no color if you are wanting something more natural, or you don't have patchy brow hairs, but if you do, this is a fantastic product. I'm not even kidding. I plan to buy many, many more.
I would just like to add that the eyebrows that grow out of my head grow straight across my face, no arch to be found, and its actually just one eyebrow, singular. So, as usual, shout out to makeup for changing the game. Otherwise, this is an actual artist rendering of who my husband would be married to:
If you take nothing else away from this post, take away that you should buy their wax brow pencil. Its $3 so if you hate it, its not that big of a deal. You won't hate it though, you'll love it. I think Ulta is even selling them now. Go check it out- tell 'em Bert sent you!
The rest of it was good, but not mind blowing. I had really high hopes for the eye palette. Their Mad for Matte 2 palette, like I said, is life changing. This one, not so much. I am a sucker for a gold metallic shadow, I'm pretty sure I have bought them all, but this palette just doesn't have a lot of pigment.
Its a nice blend of matte and metallic shades, but none of them really have any pigment to speak of. I'm wearing several of the colors in the pictures above, and you can see how subtle it is. Even watching on my finger didn't give me much pigment.
This may end up being one that I give to my daughter, because I will get too annoyed that there isn't much color payoff. The case is very, very sturdy plastic, and it has a big mirror, so the packaging is fantastic, and if I give it to my daughter, she'll never be able to get it open, but if she manages to get into it, she is going to do a lot of damage to herself, color wise. If I had this one to do over, I'd probably skip it, which is a bummer, because I have several of their other eye palettes, and they are all pretty great.
The lip duo was kind of a let down too. In the pictures on the website, those are BRIGHT PINK which is what I wanted, because they are fun in summer and going into fall. I also have the duo in their red shades and I love them. The formula itself is very, very creamy, with a satin finish. They taste great too, but not in an overly sweet or cloying way. Their actual stick lipsticks are super creamy and the reds, for sure, have great color payoff. I'd recommend their reds to anyone, but especially beginners, because its inexpensive, so you can try a lot of shades, and its really easy to apply and wear. Great red lip liners too. But I digress.
The pinks, for me, left something to be desired. Don't get my wrong, I really like both of the colors, they just aren't what I was expecting. The day color is almost a mauve nude, which I'm totally fine with, just surprised by. The night color is brighter and pinker, but not near as bright or pink as I was thinking it would be. Here are all three of the lip colors I got:
Like I said, they are all great colors, just not as bright as I was hoping. If you are looking for some more subtle pinks, the day color would literally look good on damn new everyone, and the bight pink isn't even really that bright. They are super wearable across the board.
As for the lock and seal... I don't know, you tell me. Its a little jar that looks like eye drops, and in fact, you're supposed to drop a few drops of the clear liquid into the clear plastic lid, swirl it around on the brush and then use that brush to apply your foundation or whatever. I found that the liquid made my foundation watery and streaky, and, as a result, I ended up putting on a shit ton of it, just to cover the streakiness. Did it make my foundation last better through the day? I don't know, maybe a little. The pictures in the lipstick duo were taken about 10 hours after the Berry Sorbet pictures. Does my skin look much different? I will say that I feel like it cut down on the oil production of my skin during the day, so maybe there's that.
So... thats what I have for now. Happy shopping to you! Especially when it comes to their lip products, they have a ton and they are yummy! You can't go wrong. The other items are a bit more hit and miss, except for the wax brow pencil, which is a BIG FAT HIT. In fact, I bought two more while I was typing this. I'm probably going to add some more lipstick to the ol' shopping cart as well. I might even try and buy the right color this time.